Allstate, Geico, Progressive, or State Farm is the Best Auto Insurance Companies?

Oct 11, 2023 By Triston Martin

Allstate, Geico, Progressive, and State Farm are the four most significant vehicle insurance firms in the United States, collectively holding more than half of the market share. Even though each of these companies has a well-known name across the country and offers some of the best vehicle insurance in the country.

it's hard to determine which one is ideal for you. Bank rate examined each of the four auto insurance providers to assist you in finding the best policy for your requirements.

How Bank Rate Compares These Four Auto Insurers

Finding the best auto insurance policy can be tricky, even with the help of these four well-known carriers. Bank rate has analyzed all four major national insurers to assist you in your search for the best auto insurance policy and premium, as well as customer service and third-party rankings on financial soundness and claims satisfaction.

The higher a company's total Bank rate Score, up to a maximum of 5 stars, was in each of these subcategories, the better. Allstate, Geico, Progressive, and State Farm maybe some of the top auto insurance companies in the U.S. Still, our findings show that each company offers advantages that might benefit individual drivers.


There are many ways to reduce the cost of adding a young driver to your vehicle insurance policy, but Allstate has a variety of alternatives. Good Student discounts are available to students that achieve good GPAs and participate in the teen Smart programmer.

Allstate's Drive wise, a telematics programmer that records and rewards good driving behaviors, is available in some states. They can even add accident forgiveness to their policy to avoid a premium rise in the case of an at-fault collision.


You may reduce the cost of your auto insurance premiums by obtaining a variety of discounts. It's simple to save money with Geico, thanks to an extended range of discounts available to everyone, not only good drivers and those who have numerous policies with the company. Geico offers additional discounts to specific organizations and workers of particular firms and federal agencies.


The deductible savings account is a distinctive feature of Progressive's vehicle insurance. Progressive reduces drivers' comprehensive or collision deductible with full coverage auto insurance by $50 for each policy term without an accident or infraction.

Even though it isn't available in every state, paying a small extra charge to add this optional coverage to your auto insurance policy might save you money down the road.

The State Farm

According to our analysis of typical yearly premiums, a speeding ticket or an accident for which you were at blame did not result in significantly higher State Farm rate increases. Drivers who already have a blemish on their record or are concerned about rising premiums following an accident may want to keep an eye on these figures.

As an added benefit, State Farm's Drive Safe & Save usage-based telematics programmer encourages drivers to improve their driving behaviors to save money on their auto insurance.

Allstate, Geico, Progressive, and State Farm

For the most refined vehicle insurance company for your specific scenario and needs, we've analyzed the qualities of Allstate, Geico, and Progressive, as well as State Farm, and found that each provider has its unique selling points.

Depending on how auto insurance companies apply the rating elements below, you may discover that your quoted price is higher or lower than the national average rate.

Car Insurance Rate Influencing Factors

Insurance companies use a variety of elements to calculate the cost of a driver's policy. Your vehicle, driving record, claims history, marital status, and annual mileage are all examples of this. A car insurance company may also consider characteristics like gender, ZIP code, and credit score unless state rules prohibit them.

Comparing The Customer Service of Allstate vs. Progressive

It's safe to say that all of Progressive's clients have had excellent encounters with the insurance provider. There is a minor difference between Allstate's claims service and the insurance industry average, according to J.D. Power 2020 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study results.

The firm got 876 out of 1,000 points compared to the industry average. Progressive did somewhat lower than average in the study, coming in at 856 points out of a possible 1,000.

Geico vs. State Farm: Which Is the Cheaper Option?

Geico's average rate is $1,100, around $220 less than the national average of $1,321. For State Farm, the average rate is $1,169, lower than the national average of $1,176. Among the most affordable insurance companies are Geico and State Farm.

USAA is exclusively available to service people, veterans, and their families. The rates charged by both Geico and State Farm are lower in the aggregate, but Geico's rates are still lower. A variety of criteria, including your driving record, location, car, and insurance company's discounts, will determine your auto insurance cost.

Concluding Remarks

According to our research, Progressive is a better option for most drivers when comparing Allstate and Progressive. Customer evaluations are generally excellent for Progressive; however, Allstate performs better in the claims procedure.

Related Articles