All About an Insurance Appraisal

Dec 28, 2023 By Susan Kelly

The replacement cost of a property is determined by an expert and documented in an insurance appraisal. Although appraisals are frequently utilized for insurance purposes, there is no universally accepted structure or style. What are appraisals, how do they function, and when are they required? We'll contrast insurance valuations with purchase valuations as well.

An Evaluation of What? An appraisal is a professional opinion of value given by a qualified third party, usually an appraiser or other expert in the field. Depending on the situation, you, a trusted advisor, lender, agent, or insurance company may request an appraisal.

Whether you're looking to buy or sell a house, an appraisal will detail the property's salable features and how they stack up against comparable listings in the region. Insurance companies use appraisals to determine the cost of replacing or repairing damaged property following a claim. Appraisals for older residences or those that haven't been inspected recently may be requested.

Appraisals for Homeowners' Insurance

Appraisals for homeowners insurance determine how much it would cost to replace your property, not how much it is worth on the open market. Since land is not vulnerable to theft, fire, or any other risks that these valuations account for, it is not included in the calculations.

Purchasing Insurance Some insurance companies, particularly those dealing with more expensive houses, will send an appraiser to your property when you purchase a policy to estimate how much it would cost to rebuild.

However, other businesses may utilize algorithms to estimate the price of rebuilding your house based on its square footage and year of construction. Review the information your insurer has on file concerning your property if you have any doubts about the accuracy of their assessment.

Insurance companies may also need a formal appraisal of unusual or valuable things before agreeing to cover them. This appraisal should include the items to be insured, their condition, and their projected value relative to similar products on the market. To protect yourself against financial loss due to such events, you may need to invest in supplemental insurance or an umbrella rider.

Estimating the Cost of Repairs

In most cases, you won't have to pay anything out of pocket to have a professional adjuster evaluate the damage to your property because your insurer will cover the cost. However, these adjusters are paid based on a percentage of the total amount recovered in a homeowner's, company owner's, tenant's, or commercial property's insurance claim. 45 The appraisal provision in your policy might be used if you disagree with the adjuster's valuation or the settlement amount.

If you and your insurer can't agree on something, one of you may be able to request an appraisal in writing. Each side will then appoint an outside expert to evaluate, and they will have 20 days to share that person's details with the other side.

The two valuers then have 15 days to mutually agree on an umpire, after which you or the insurer can ask a judge to make the decision. After arriving at their damage estimates, the appraisers negotiate a common valuation of the losses. If they cannot agree, the umpire will decide based on the specifics of both appraisals.

An insurer might also propose arbitration to settle a contested claim's value by having a third party hear arguments on both sides and then make a decision. You can register a complaint with your state against the insurance company or insurance adjuster if you're displeased with the valuation or appraisal procedure. Contact the Department of Insurance or Office of Insurance Regulation in your state for information on filing a complaint.

Appraisal for Insurance Purposes vs. Appraisal

Appraisals are commonplace in real estate transactions and are also performed for insurance purposes. There are some parallels between these two evaluations, but they also have some key distinctions. A comparison can be made between insurance valuations and purchase prices as follows.

Purpose Appraisals for insurance and sales purposes attempt to place a monetary value on a property. The cost to replace your home and its valuables in the event of a total loss is calculated in an insurance appraisal. In contrast, the market value is determined in a purchase evaluation.

Appraisers specializing in insurance have the training and tools to calculate an accurate replacement cost estimate. The "cost approach" is a part of a property evaluation that determines the worth of a house independent of its location. However, the result is incorporated into a property value rather than used to determine insurance premiums.

Related Articles